VTI vs VOO: which is better, and how much do they overlap?
VTI and VOO overlap by about 88% by weight: every company in VOO is also in VTI, and those S&P 500 companies make up about 88% of VTI. Both cost 0.03% a year, and over the 10 years to June 30, 2026, VOO returned about 15.5% a year and VTI about 15.0%, including dividends. The choice comes down to whether you want VTI’s other 12%, about 3,000 mid- and small-cap stocks, and what switching would cost in tax if you already own one fund in a taxable account.
The sections below explain what the other 12% holds, why VOO has led, and how holding both changes your allocation. They also compare the pair with VT and QQQ and cover what to check before choosing a fund.
How VTI and VOO differ, and how much they overlap
To calculate overlap by weight, take the smaller weight for each stock the funds share and add those weights together. VTI holds each S&P 500 company at a slightly lower weight than VOO, so the overlap equals VTI’s share in S&P 500 companies: about 88%.
| VTI | VOO | |
|---|---|---|
| Index | Morningstar US Total Market (the former CRSP US Total Market Index, renamed in 2026) | S&P 500 |
| Holdings | About 3,500 | About 500 companies |
| Expense ratio | 0.03% | 0.03% |
| Top 10 holdings combined | 34.7% | 39.1% |
| Nvidia, the largest holding | 7.13% | 8.39% |
| Rule for adding a company | Size and liquidity, on a set schedule | Committee decision, after four quarters of combined profit |
Holdings and weights as of September 30, 2026; overlap from ETF Research Center, November 2026. For research purposes only.
The extra 12% is spread across about 3,000 companies, and most make up less than 0.05% of VTI each. That’s why the two funds’ monthly returns move almost together.
Koyfin is an investment research platform that lets you compare VTI’s mid- and small-cap weights with VOO’s. Add VTI to a model portfolio with VOO as the benchmark, then open the Styles exhibit on the Exposure tab.
Mutual fund versions of the same portfolios
FXAIX and VOO both hold the S&P 500. FXAIX is a Fidelity mutual fund that charges 0.015% and trades once a day at the closing price. VOO is an ETF that charges 0.03% and trades all day at any broker.
VTSAX is the mutual fund share class of the same Vanguard fund as VTI, so it holds the same stocks. In an overlap check, count each of these pairs as one fund.
VTI vs VOO performance: why VOO has led
VOO has returned about 15.5% a year over the 10 years to June 30, 2026, and VTI about 15.0%, including dividends. That return gap comes entirely from the 12% in smaller companies. VTI’s smaller stocks had to trail the S&P 500 by about 3.5 points a year for VTI to fall behind by about 0.4 points a year (0.43 divided by 0.12).
The fund with the higher return has changed over time. Smaller companies led from 2001 to 2013, when VTI was ahead of the S&P 500, and large companies have led in most years since, with 2016 and 2020 the exceptions. Choosing based on the last 10 years assumes large companies will keep leading.
Holding both VTI and VOO
Holding both in one account halves your mid- and small-cap allocation to about 6% instead of 12%. Choose the mix based on how much you want in smaller companies:
- No separate bet on company size: hold one. VTI owns every company from soon after it lists; VOO adds a company only after the S&P committee picks it.
- A specific allocation to smaller companies: hold VOO plus an extended-market fund such as VXF, which holds the US stocks outside the S&P 500. About 88% VOO and 12% VXF recreates VTI. Adding more VXF increases your allocation to smaller companies.
If you already own VOO and want VTI’s mix, putting new money into VXF lets you reach that mix without selling. The tax cost of selling one fund to buy the other is in the third pitfall below.
Holding VOO in one account and VTI in another is common, because each plan offers different funds.
Overlap for other popular ETF pairs
The table compares overlap by weight for other popular fund pairs and explains what each fund adds:
| Pair | Overlap by weight | What the second fund adds |
|---|---|---|
| VOO vs QQQ | 52% | QQQ holds the 100 largest non-financial companies listed on Nasdaq, at higher weights, with no banks |
| VTI vs VT | 61% | VT adds stocks outside the US, about 38% of the fund |
| QQQ vs VGT | 51% | VGT holds only information technology, so it leaves out Amazon, Alphabet, Meta and Tesla |
| VUG vs QQQ | 59% | VUG holds large growth companies on any exchange; QQQ holds Nasdaq-listed staples and utilities |
Overlap from ETF Research Center, November 2026. For research purposes only.
For SPY vs VOO, SCHD vs VYM and VTI vs SCHD, and for what overlap does to your sector weights, see how to check ETF overlap in your portfolio.
Where ETF pair comparisons go wrong, and how to avoid it
An overlap score and a 10-year return chart can miss differences that affect your choice. Check how much each fund depends on its largest companies, how it selects holdings, and what switching would cost if you already own the other fund.
VTI barely lowers your exposure to the largest companies
The check: if you’re worried about concentration in a few tech giants, compare top-10 weights before choosing between VTI and VOO. A difference of about 4 points does little to reduce that concentration.
Why the 3,000 extra holdings miss it: VTI weights each company by its market value. The extra stocks share the 12% allocation, so each large company’s weight falls by only about an eighth.
| VTI | VOO | |
|---|---|---|
| Top 10 holdings (September 30, 2026) | 34.7% | 39.1% |
| 2022 total return | About -19.5% | About -18.2% |
In 2022, when the largest companies fell hardest, VTI still fell more, because its small caps fell too. The equal-weight fund RSP lost about 11.6%.
What to do: to lower concentration, use an equal-weight S&P 500 fund such as RSP, where each company starts at about 0.2% of the fund, or hold a fixed slice in a mid- or small-cap fund. In Koyfin, chart VTI, VOO and RSP from the start of 2022 with total return to see how each held up.
QQQ picks companies by where they list
The check: before comparing QQQ with VOO, VUG or VGT, look at the large companies it can’t hold and the ones it holds only because of their listing.
Why the comparison misses it: comparisons with growth and tech funds can suggest QQQ selects companies for their growth. Its index takes the 100 largest non-financial companies listed on Nasdaq.
- Eli Lilly, Visa, Mastercard and Oracle trade on the New York Stock Exchange, so QQQ can’t hold them.
- PepsiCo, Costco, Mondelez and several utilities are in it because they list on Nasdaq.
- Walmart joined the Nasdaq-100 on January 20, 2026, a month after moving its listing from the NYSE, with no change to its business.
What to do: compare QQQ with VUG for large growth companies on any exchange, or with VGT for technology alone. In Koyfin, make a model portfolio of 100% QQQ, set VUG as the benchmark, and open Equity Sectors in the Vs. Benchmark view to see where QQQ is over- and underweight.
Switching between similar funds in a taxable account usually costs more than it gains
The check: if you already own one fund of a near-identical pair in a taxable account, keep it and send new money to the one you prefer. Switch only inside an IRA or 401(k), or when the sale is at a loss.
Why comparison pages miss it: they recommend a fund without accounting for the tax you’d pay to sell the one you own. For example, here’s the cost of switching a $60,000 VTI investment in a taxable account that’s now worth $90,000:
| Gain realized by selling to buy VOO | $30,000 |
| Federal tax at 15% | About $4,500 |
| Left to invest in VOO | $85,500 |
VOO then has to beat VTI by about 5.3% in total to break even. That would take more than 12 years at its recent lead of about 0.4 points a year, and either fund could lead in future.
The same applies to funds on one index. QQQM costs 0.15% a year and QQQ 0.18%, so switching $50,000 of QQQ with a $20,000 gain to QQQM creates about $3,000 in tax to save $15 a year in fees.
What to do: enter your lots with purchase dates in Koyfin’s My Portfolio to see the gain on each one before you decide. Use your broker’s cost basis records to confirm the tax before selling.
Compare the pair you’re deciding on
Create a free Koyfin account, make a model portfolio of one fund with the other as the benchmark, and compare their sector, style and country weights on the Exposure tab. Add both to the Holdings Matrix to see each company’s weight in each fund. New accounts get 7 days of full access.
Common questions about VTI vs VOO
Are VTI and VOO the same?
VOO holds about 500 large US companies and VTI holds about 3,500 US companies of every size, though the S&P 500 companies make up about 88% of VTI. Their returns usually differ by less than a point a year.
What if I invested $1,000 in VTI 10 years ago?
With dividends reinvested, $1,000 put into VTI on June 30, 2016 grew to about $4,058 by June 30, 2026, a total return of 305.84%. The same amount in VOO grew to about $4,216 (321.55%).
Which is better for a Roth IRA, VOO or VTI?
Trades and dividends inside a Roth IRA aren’t taxed, so you can switch between VTI and VOO without a tax bill. The choice is the same as in any account: whether you want VTI’s extra 12% in mid- and small-cap stocks.
Does Warren Buffett recommend VOO or VTI?
In his 2013 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, Buffett said the trustee for his wife’s inheritance should put 90% in a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund, suggesting Vanguard’s, and 10% in short-term government bonds. He didn’t compare it with a total-market fund.
What does VT add compared with VTI and VOO?
VT holds the US market plus stocks outside the US, which made up about 38% of the fund in November 2026. That’s why VTI and VT overlap by only 61% by weight, while VTI and VOO hold only US companies.
Do I need both VOO and QQQ?
About half of QQQ’s weight is already in VOO, so you only need to add QQQ if you want more exposure to the largest Nasdaq companies. Choose how much you want to invest, for example 20% to 30% of your stocks.
How do I find large-cap ETFs that cover the S&P 500 without overlap?
Hold one S&P 500 or large-cap fund as the core, and add only funds whose holdings sit outside it, such as an extended-market fund for mid and small caps or an international fund. Check each addition for overlap by weight, and treat anything above about 50% as largely duplicating your core fund.
Comparing ETFs in Koyfin
Can I compare VTI and VOO performance in Koyfin?
Add both tickers to one chart and switch to total return to include dividends, then pick a range. Koyfin’s total return history for VTI starts at the end of 2001 and VOO’s in 2010, so add SPY for the S&P 500 before 2010.
Can I see how much two ETFs overlap in Koyfin?
Add both funds to a model portfolio or My Portfolio and open the Holdings Matrix, which shows every company once with its weight in each fund. Download the table and add up the smaller weight for each shared company to get overlap by weight.
Can I compare the top 10 holdings of VTI and VOO in Koyfin?
Open each fund’s Holdings page (the ticker, then HDS) to see its holdings sorted by weight, next to a sector breakdown. The top 10 made up 34.7% of VTI and 39.1% of VOO in the September 30, 2026 holdings.
Editorial note
Our insights are derived solely from historical information and analyst predictions, employing an impartial approach. Please note that our articles do not serve as financial guidance.